| Platinum | South Lanes |
| Gold | T-Jo's Pizza |
| Silver | Pizza Villa West Salem |
| Bronze | Pizza King Lacrosse |
| Top Pick | Al's State Road Pizzaria |
| Top Pick | Big Al's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Big Als Too |
| Top Pick | Hunter's Last Chance Bar and Grill |
| Top Pick | Sloopy's Alma Mater Tavern |
| Top Pick | Uno Venti Pizzeria |