| Platinum | Pickerman's Soup & Sandwich Shop |
| Gold | Milwaukee Burger Company |
| Silver | Lindy's Subs & Salads |
| Bronze | Pizza King Lacrosse |
| Top Pick | Ardie's Restaurant and Flipside Pub & Grill |
| Top Pick | Cousins Subs |
| Top Pick | Jimmy's North Star |
| Top Pick | Midway Deli |
| Top Pick | Neuies Vogue |
| Top Pick | Subway |