| Platinum | 6-11 Crystals and Sundry |
| Gold | Debo's Vintage Emporium |
| Gold | Practically Posh |
| Silver | Sunshine Floral |
| Silver | TJ's Cheddarheads Gift Gallery |
| Bronze | Johnson Livings LLC |
| Top Pick | Bean & Baum |
| Top Pick | Finnottes Nut & Chocolate Shop |
| Top Pick | Natty West |
| Top Pick | Portraitpuzzles.Com |