| Platinum | Pizza Ranch |
| Gold | Bigboar BBQ & Catering |
| Silver | Pogy's Catering |
| Bronze | Schmitty's Time Out Tavern |
| Top Pick | Pickerman's Soup & Sandwich Shop |
| Top Pick | Piggy's Restaurant & Blues Lounge |
| Top Pick | Pizza Villa West Salem |
| Top Pick | Premier Catering |
| Top Pick | Schindoggies At Cardinals Nest |
| Top Pick | Serves You Right |