| Platinum | Nutbush City Limits |
| Gold | La Crosse Family Restaurant |
| Silver | Rosie's Cafe |
| Bronze | Hungry Peddler |
| Top Pick | Kaddy's Kafe |
| Top Pick | Lovechild Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Neuies Vogue |
| Top Pick | Pizza Villa West Salem |
| Top Pick | The Farmhouse Eatery & Gifts |
| Top Pick | Ye Old Style Inn |