| Platinum | Angelini's Ristorante |
| Gold | Sagra |
| Silver | Pizza Villa West Salem |
| Bronze | Lovechild Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Ciatti's Italian Grill |
| Top Pick | Olive Garden Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Osteria Amelia |
| Top Pick | Pizza Corral |
| Top Pick | Rocky Rococo Pan Style Pizza |
| Top Pick | Uno Venti Pizzeria |