| Platinum | Pizza Ranch |
| Gold | The Sports Nut |
| Silver | River Rats |
| Bronze | Pizza Villa West Salem |
| Top Pick | Buffalo Wild Wings |
| Top Pick | Howie's on La Crosse |
| Top Pick | Milwaukee Burger Company |
| Top Pick | Neuies Vogue |
| Top Pick | Nutbush City Limits |
| Top Pick | Schmitty's Time Out Tavern |