| Platinum | The Warren Collection |
| Gold | Antique Center of La Crosse |
| Silver | Relic Road |
| Bronze | Gasoline Alley Toys, Antiques |
| Top Pick | Buckboard Antiques |
| Top Pick | Caledonia St. Antique Mall |
| Top Pick | Oolala! Consign and Furniture Annex |
| Top Pick | The Second-Hand Shack |
| Top Pick | Treasure's On Main |
| Top Pick | White Buffalo Thriftery |