| Platinum | The Warren Collection |
| Gold | T.J. Maxx & HomeGoods |
| Silver | Oolala! Consign and Furniture Annex |
| Bronze | Natty West |
| Top Pick | Bauer's Garden Center Market & Nursery |
| Top Pick | Hobby Lobby |
| Top Pick | Jade Willow |
| Top Pick | Practically Posh |
| Top Pick | Savvy Home Consignments |
| Top Pick | White Buffalo Thriftery |