| Platinum | Harvest Lane Treasures |
| Gold | Goodwill |
| Silver | Oolala! Consign and Furniture Annex |
| Bronze | Style Encore |
| Top Pick | Good Steward Resale Store |
| Top Pick | Plato's Closet |
| Top Pick | Savvy Home Consignments |
| Top Pick | Secondedit |
| Top Pick | The Second-Hand Shack |